Impact Kryptonite: The Trap for Purpose-Driven Business

Introduction

In the world of impact-driven scale-ups, the desire to do good is often the engine that powers early growth, attracts talent, and opens doors to influential networks. But what if that same desire, left unchecked, becomes a hidden liability, a “kryptonite” that undermines commercial success and limits the very impact these businesses seek to deliver? Drawing on a candid conversation with a senior leader who has navigated both global FMCG giants and high-growth impact ventures, this blog explores the paradoxes of scaling for purpose-led companies, the human capital challenges that emerge, and why commercial discipline, not just good intentions, is essential for sustainable impact.

The Opportunity: Impact as a Double-Edged Sword

For many founders and early employees, the mission to create positive change is a powerful motivator. It attracts early adopters, secures initial funding, and can even win the attention of major corporates eager to associate with the next big thing in sustainability. However, as our interviewee observed, this very appeal can create “false market positives.” Large organizations may express interest, sponsor pilot projects, or allocate relatively  small budgets to support an impact venture, not because they see long-term value, but because it helps them advance their sustainability goals or meet PR needs.

This dynamic is especially pronounced as companies move from £5 million to £20 million in revenue. At this stage, the business is no longer a scrappy startup but not yet a mature enterprise. The temptation is to chase every opportunity that looks like validation, even when the underlying buying signals are weak. The result? Resources are spread thin, teams are pulled in too many directions, and the business risks stalling before it can achieve true scale.

The human element can then compound this challenge. Early team members, deeply invested in the mission, may push to double down on new impact initiatives, seeking the excitement of fresh challenges rather than the discipline of refining and scaling core offerings. While this drive is admirable, it can inadvertently hinder the company’s ability to focus, iterate, and deliver repeatable value at scale.

The Solution: Commercial Discipline and Human Capital Evolution

So how can impact-driven businesses avoid the kryptonite trap and unlock their full potential? The answer lies in a blend of commercial discipline, honest self-assessment, and strategic talent management.

1. Ruthless Focus on Real Market Demand

The most successful scale-ups learn to distinguish between “goodwill” projects and genuine commercial opportunities. This means saying no to pilots or partnerships that don’t have a clear path to scale, even if they come with prestigious logos or short-term revenue. As our interviewee put it, “There were times where the emphasis was too much on selling a couple more projects, even though we knew that it was basically to repeat learnings we already had.” Instead, resources should be concentrated on initiatives with the highest probability of long-term success, those that deliver repeatable value to paying customers.

2. Professionalizing the Team Without Losing the Mission

As companies grow, the skills and mindsets that drove early success may not be the ones needed for the next phase. Many early employees excel in creativity and resourcefulness but may lack experience with structured personal development, performance management, or scaling operations. Leaders must identify development needs, provide honest feedback, and support transitions, whether that means upskilling, moving individuals into new roles (such as foundation or special projects), or, when necessary, facilitating respectful exits.

This process is not about diluting the mission. Rather, it’s about ensuring that the right people are in the right roles for the company’s current stage. As the business matures, the “purity” of impact may become less direct, but the quantum of impact increases as the company’s reach expands. Helping team members understand where they fit on the “impact maturity” curve, and supporting them to find roles that align with their strengths, can unlock both personal fulfillment and organizational effectiveness.

3. Bridging the Talent Gap: Secondments and Cross-Pollination

One innovative solution discussed was the potential for secondment schemes between large corporates and scaling impact businesses. Many experienced professionals in big companies crave the chance to make a difference but are hesitant to leap into the unknown of a startup. Structured secondments could allow these individuals to bring commercial acumen and operational expertise to scale-ups, without requiring a permanent career change. For corporates, this approach retains talent and injects fresh perspective; for scale-ups, it provides access to skills that are often in short supply.

The key is to design these programs with clear value propositions for all parties, manage expectations, and ensure there is a pathway for return or transition. Such cross-pollination could become a powerful lever for accelerating the professionalization of the impact sector.

The Result: Maximizing Net Impact Through Strategic Focus

When impact-driven businesses embrace commercial discipline and invest in the evolution of their teams, they unlock the ability to scale sustainably and maximize their net positive effect on the world. This doesn’t mean abandoning the mission; it means delivering on it at a much greater scale.

• Companies that focus on repeatable, scalable services are better positioned to attract genuine customers, secure long-term revenue, and build resilient business models.
• Teams that evolve with the business, through upskilling, role transitions, or respectful exits, maintain momentum and avoid the stagnation that can come from misaligned talent.
• Cross-sector secondments and advisory roles create new pathways for talent to flow into the impact economy, enriching both the scale-up and corporate worlds.

Ultimately, the journey from startup to scale-up is a test of both purpose and pragmatism. The most impactful companies are those that can hold both in balance, staying true to their mission while making the tough choices required for commercial success.

Call to Action

Are you a founder, leader, or investor navigating the challenges of scaling an impact-driven business? Join the House of Impact Talent Network to connect with experienced professionals, access strategic talent solutions, and share insights on building the next generation of sustainable enterprises. Let’s turn purpose into scalable, lasting impact, together.

‍